Transparency speech marks International Right to Know Day
‘Transparency is not just about what the authorities choose to reveal to citizens; but what citizens have a right to ask to see,’ Information Commissioner, Christopher Graham, said today, in a speech to mark International Right to Know Day 2011.
Information Commissioner, Christopher Graham, said:
“We need to ensure that there is no gap between the right to know rhetoric and the reality of a ‘don’t tell ‘em’ mentality that all too frequently frustrates the citizen.
“I believe that an active and independent ICO can help make a practical reality of the transparency agenda. Not just supporting the direction of travel, but helping to reach a common goal. Delivering a Right to Know 2.0. The reality, not just the rhetoric. The difference between seeing it through – and seeing through it.”
When it comes to openness, HRM is by far the worst in the country, a new audit reveals.
The municipality took 129 days to release an incomplete copy of a $1-million contract with Coastal Restoration and Masonry Ltd. for their repair work to the face of city hall, Newspapers Canada’s national freedom of information audit states.
The audit, conducted from January to May 2011 and released this week, measured ompleteness and response times for standard freedom-of-information requests at all levels of government. HRM received a grade of F for both.
“At the municipal level in Nova Scotia, it’s a disaster,” said John Hinds, president and CEO of Newspapers Canada. “I think it’s really hard, if it’s going to take you four or five months to get information, to claim that you run an open government.”
Acting as what it called a citizen, the audit asked the municipality to provide a copy of its contract with Coastal. After HRM consulted with the contractor, the contract was to be released with some information deleted. Coastal then asked Nova Scotia’s freedom-of-information officer to review that decision, leading to nearly five months worth of delay.
Municipal spokesperson Shaune MacKinlay said the municipality has to abide by legislation, which led to the long wait. “We have a serious concern with the methodology, or the lack of methodology, in how Newspapers Canada approached the project,” she said.
But Hinds said most municipalities in Canada returned similar requests within 30 days. “It’s great to hide behind process … but nobody else seemed to have the challenge that Halifax did,” he said.
How they ranked:
Grades in completeness and speed of disclosure:
Saskatchewan municipalities: A
Newfoundland and Labrador municipalities: A
Alberta municipalities: A
Ontario municipalities: B
Nova Scotia municipalities: F





